Broken Promises - What's the Difference Between Mutual and Mirror Wills?

There can often be a misunderstanding regarding the difference between mutual Wills and mirror Wills.

It is a basic principle that any party is entitled to revoke a Will that he or she has made at any time and to execute a new Will in different terms. This also applies in the case of mirror Wills but the law is prepared to intervene in the case of mutual Wills.

What is a mirror Will?

Mirror Wills are executed by two people, usually spouses or cohabitees, usually at the same time, in identical terms, which usually provide for the whole of the estate of the first testator to die to pass to the second testator on the basis that on the death of the second testator the whole of the combined estate then passes to agreed beneficiaries.

An issue arises if the second testator receives the estate of the first testator but then changes his or her Will and leaves his or her estate to different beneficiaries.  In that case the principle that the second testator is free to change his or her Will applies and there is nothing that the disappointed beneficiaries can do.

What is a mutual Will?

Mutual Wills however are Wills in which the two testators have made a specific agreement as to their disposal of their property on death and again they execute separate Wills in the same terms (or a joint Will) but where in addition the parties agree that the survivor shall be bound by the arrangement in the form of an agreement by the parties not to revoke their mutual Wills. This agreement is usually written into the mutual Wills themselves. When the first of the two testators dies, without having revoked his or her mutual Will the survivor becomes bound by the arrangement and he or she is no longer at liberty to ignore the original agreement.

The principle that the survivor can execute a new Will still applies but the property which was left under the original mutual Will becomes subject to a constructive trust and the persons originally named as beneficiaries of this property are entitled to receive it irrespective of what the replacement Will says.

The agreement not to revoke can be proved by evidence other than a written agreement and the mutual Will itself but there is a high burden of proof if the agreement not to revoke is not clearly set out in writing.

What happens in the case of re-marriage?

Difficulties concerning mutual Wills often arise in circumstances where the survivor re-marries after the first testator's death and acquires a second family with the issue of them likely to benefit at the expense of his or her first family.

Disappointed beneficiaries who believe that they were mentioned in mutual Wills but have now been wrongly disinherited by subsequent Wills should seek legal advice.

A simple promise by a testator to leave property to another third party under a Will does not provide a cause of action if that Will is subsequently changed but there may be other grounds for bringing a claim if the person to whom the promise was made acted to his or her detriment on the strength of the promise.

We can help

Clough & Willis has years of experience in helping both couples and individuals when it comes to the creation and execution of Wills.  Our qualified, friendly and approachable team is dedicated to finding the best solution for you and your family, and we will take all of your circumstances into account throughout the process.

Contact us today by calling 0800 083 0815, or fill in an online enquiry form and we will contact you back.

What Our Clients Say

I was very impressed with Sallys patient, knowledgeable ideas and explanations. The law can be very confusing. Her genuine wish to help was much appreciated.

Mrs Baumber

I am part sighted and things that I have found hard to read have been read to me with understanding and patience. I feel well served.

Mrs Parkinson

I am now happy that my will and Lasting Power of Attorney has been prepared by a solicitor. In past years it was through the bank. They are not solicitors. Now I can see the difference, Miss Sally Cook was so professional and very thorough from start to finish. A very big thank you to Sally for everything. Also thank you to Clough & Willis Solicitors.

Mrs Wareing

Everything that they did was done without any bother at all. Their professionalism could not be improved.

Mr Greaves

Very satisfied with the service from Sally Cook - very helpful and professional

Mr & Mrs McColgan

We found the whole process quick and stress free! Sally Cook was both professional and efficient and we were very pleased with the service we received.

Mrs Halliwell

I was very pleased to meet with Sally Cook, for her to prepare my complete new Will, and Lasting Power of Attorney. It was not easy for me to understand all of that, but Sally guided me through. Sally took the time to explain to me the content of both, nothing was too much trouble and I can't thank her enough for everything she did. From myself thank you so much Sally.

Mr R Wareing

Sally Cook was very professional and explained to me what a Will consisted off and dealt with the matter quickly and very efficiently would recommend to anyone.

Miss T Wareing

Sally was helpful, friendly, professional and very approachable. I felt completely at ease and important to her as a client. Keep up the good work.

Mrs Matthews

They were very kind to me when my husband died.

Mrs Garner

Many thanks to Sally for the excellent service we received.

Mr Meadowcroft

I found Sally Cook to be very helpful, approachable and professional.

Mrs Gilbert

Read all testimonials